“Science of Reading:” Is it the Answer to our Literacy Problems?

Authors

  • Dory Lightfoot Independent Scholar

Abstract

Recently the “science of reading” has dominated discourse on literacy. Advocates assert that it is the only scientific way to understand reading and literacy instruction, and that every other understanding is incorrect and unscientific. Advocates of the science of reading believe phonics and decoding are correct while other views are incorrect. There are laws in forty states mandating phonics instruction in schools and explicitly forbidding the use of other methodologies. In this essay I question this orthodoxy. I first examine the scientific model on which the science of reading is based and questions its adequacy for human subjects’ research. I then unpack the way science of reading discourse positions teachers as ignorant and poorly educated, and shifts power away from teachers, schools and local administrators toward distant experts. Finally, with help from the voices of classroom teachers, I offer other ways we can understand the teaching and learning of reading.[1]

Downloads

Published

2026-11-17